Wednesday, 8 January 2014

No need for differentiation

For decades, strategy gurus have been telling firms to differentiate. From Michael Porter to Costas Markides and through the Blue Oceans of Kim and Mauborgne, strategy scholars have been urging executives to distinguish their firm’s offerings and carve out a unique market position. Because if you just do the same thing as your competitors, they claim, there will be nothing left for you than to engage in fierce price competition, which brings everyone’s margins to zero – if not below.

Yet, at the same time, we see many industries in which firms do more or less the same thing. And among those firms offering more or less the same thing, we often see very different levels of success and profitability. How come? What explains the apparent discrepancy?

To understand this, you have to realise that the field of Strategy arose from Economics. The strategy thinkers who first entered the scene in the 1980s and 90s based their recommendations on economic theory, which would indeed suggest that, as a competitor, you have to somehow be different to make money. Over the last decade or two, however, we have been seeing more and more research in Strategy that builds on insights from Sociology, which complements the earlier economics-based theories, yet may be better equipped to understand this particular issue.

Consider, for example, the case of McKinsey. Clearly, McKinsey is a highly successful professional services firm, making rather healthy margins. But is their offering really so different from others, like BCG, or Bain? They all offer more or less the same thing: a bunch of clever, reasonably well-trained analytical people wearing pin-striped suits and using a problem-solving approach to make recommendations about general management problems. McKinsey’s competitive advantage apparently does not come from how it differentiates its offering.

The trick is that when there is uncertainty about the quality of a product or service, firms do not have to rely on differentiation in order to obtain a competitive advantage. Whether you’re a law firm or a hairdresser, people will find it difficult – at least beforehand – to assess how good you really are. But customers, nonetheless, have to pick one.  McKinsey, of course, offers the most uncertain product of all: Strategy advice. When you hire them – or any other consulting firm – you cannot foretell the quality of what they are going to do and deliver. In fact, even when you have the advice in your hands (in the form of a report or, more likely, a powerpoint “deck”), you can still not quite assess its quality. Worse, even years after you might have implemented it, you cannot really say if it was any good, because lots of factors influence firm performance, and whether the advice helped or hampered will forever remain opaque.

Research in Organizational Sociology shows that when there is such uncertainty, buyers rely on other signals to decide whether to purchase, such as the seller’s status, its social network ties, and prior relationships. And that is what McKinsey does so well. They carefully foster their status by claiming to always hire the brightest people and work for the best companies. They also actively nurture their immense network by making sure former employees become “alumni” who then not infrequently end up hiring McKinsey. And they make sure to carefully manage their existing client relationships, so that no less than 85 percent of their business now comes from existing customers.

Status, social networks, and prior relationships are the forgotten drivers of firm performance. Underestimate them at your peril. How you manage them should be as much part of your strategizing as analyses of differentiation, value propositions, and customer segments. 

11 comments:

Erik Steiner said...

Freeky indeed...Freek nicely ends his argument by contradicting himself-Mckinsey differentiates EXACTLY through stronger social networks,more discerning hiring practices,groundbreaking research. Competes nicely vis a vis Bain and BCG,but how different is M from the thousands of less known consulting firms??

Mckinsey also differentiates strongly by pricing at a level mediocre firms cant afford. This also contributes nicely to stregthening differentiation along those other dimensions.

Umar Saeed said...

I think we can not ignore the importance of differentiation as it allows us to set skimming prices. Differentiation also helps us to establish unique brands just like Apple did. Now it is also very important for online services or e-commerce companies. Thanks for sharing

. said...

Actually, when the product is opaque and uncertain, those "other signals" from the paragraph before the last one are becoming the basement of differentiation.

David Channon said...

Status, social networks, prior relationships...these are differentiation, all part of a firms brand, identity and culture.

The example of McKinsey not being different from other consulting firms is the same as saying Waitrose and Lidl are the same because they both sell baked beans.

They are clearly differentiated by their strategy of competing at different ends of the market.

Dora Ali said...

They are clearly differentiated by their strategy of competing at different ends of the market.http://www.afu.ac.ae/en/vision/

Devid said...

All Institute in India
Top 10 Nursing Institute in India
Ayurveda Institute in India
Top 10 MBA Institute in India
Top 10 Law Institute in India
Top 10 MCA Institute in India
Top 10 Dental Institute in India
B.Arch Institute in India
Engg Institute in India
MCA Institute in India
Top 10 Medical Institute in India

Mrs Clara said...

Good Day,

I am MRS JANA MOORE from UK,a private loan lender. Do you need an urgent loan? You are in a financial crisis or needs money to start your own business? Do you need a loan to settle your debt or pay bills or start a nice business ?Have you been denied of loan from Bank? Or do you need a loan to pay off bills? worry no more, Your help comes now,contact us today at (BraydenOffshoreLoans@hotmail.com)


THANKS.

Tom Dcruze said...

Hi,

We specialize in global database resources for the international direct marketing community. Our company is primarily international data compile and research services.

B2B Marketing Database
CEO Email Database CFO USA Database
Directors Email Lists

Mike Robert said...

NO UPFRONT PAYMENTS INVOLVED
Hello,

What are your Financial needs?
We give out loans from a minimum of $5,000.00 to a maximum of $10,000,000.00 with comfortable duration that ranges from 1 to 30 years at a very reduced interest rate of 3%.

Do you need a business loan?
Do you need a personal loan?
Do you want to buy a car?
Do you want to refinance?
Do you need a mortgage loan?

Do you need a huge capital to start off your business proposal or expansion? Have you lost hope and you think there is no way out, and your financial burdens still persists?
Please do not hesitate to contact us for possible business co-operation

Contact us via email: (mikerobertloans1@gmail.com)

Drone Topaz said...

I GOT A FAST LOAN @ 2% INTEREST RATE with Victoriafinancier@outlook.com

Victoria Lawson Financier help me when I was desperately in need of funds to clear debt while my husband was in hospital for surgical Treatment after he had a serious gassy accident in the factory. We spend all we have on his emergency survival treatment. After 3 Months, Doctors request for more money for a major operation because of the gas effect which was what makes me plead for funds assistance and look for loan online. After i read a lots of testimony of how Victoria Lawson Financier has help different persons, I also contacted her with { victoriafinancier@outlook.com } as directed by each testimony that i read. I explain how urgent i need the funds desperately And She gave me their policies which i agreed and my loan amount was transferred into my bank account. It was a right decision to have contacted her company. I will also advice every one in need of funds to contact Victoria Lawson Via Her Email: victoriafinancier@outlook.com

Patrick Morgam said...

Aufmerksamkeit,
Beantragen Sie eine schnelle und bequeme Darlehen, um Rechnungen, Weihnachtskredit, Hypothekendarlehen, Konsolidierungsdarlehen zu bezahlen und ein neues Geschäft zu beginnen oder Ihre Projekte zu einem billigsten Zinssatz von 3% zu refinanzieren. Bitte kontaktieren Sie uns heute über: Jaysonloanfirm@gmail.com mit Darlehen benötigt.
Wir sind zertifiziert, registriert und legitime Kreditgeber.
Sie können mit uns heute in Verbindung treten, wenn Sie am Erhalten dieses Darlehens interessiert sind, in Verbindung treten mit uns zu mehr Information über den Darlehensprozeß, Prozess wie die Darlehensbedingungen und wie das Darlehen auf Sie übertragen wird. Wir benötigen Ihre dringende Antwort, wenn Sie interessiert sind.

Erste Informationen benötigt von Ihnen:

Ganze Namen:…………
Land:…………...
Bundesland: ...............
Telefonnummer:…………
Dauer:…………
Ausgeliehener Betrag: ......... ..
Haus Adresse / Büro Adresse: ..........
Beruf:............
Monatliches Einkommen:……….
Familienstand:………..
Alter Geschlecht:…………..
Darlehen Zweck:…………..
Haben Sie sich für ein Darlehen vor? (Ja oder Nein):...


HINWEIS: Alle Antworten sollten an folgende Adresse gesendet werden:
Jaysonloanfirm@gmail.com
Für schnelle Verarbeitung.
Danke.